Coal-fired brick oven magic has been happening here since this NYC pizza institution claimed its spot in the Theater District. The thin-crust pies emerge from those legendary ovens with perfectly charred crusts and that distinctive coal-fired flavor that separates John's from the pretenders. The no-slice policy means you're getting whole pies of New York pizza perfection, served in a casual atmosphere that's perfect for groups heading to shows or families exploring the city. It's old-school NYC pizza craftsmanship in the heart of the action.